Are you a pizza lover dreaming of a perfect slice in Montclair?
Look no further.
This article will take you through the best pizzerias in Montclair.
From classic Italian pastries to unique regional specialties, each pizzeria has something special to offer.
Sit back and discover the best pizza in Montclair by checking out the must-visit places below.
1. Oh, pizza
Wierzbowa Street 7 N
Montclair, New Jersey 07042
(973) 783-9200
Ah' Pizz is a BYOB pizzeria serving Italian cuisine since 2010.
Why we recommend this pizzeria
If you're looking for the best pizzeria in Montclair, Ah' Pizz is a fantastic choice.
This is a warm and welcoming pizzeria with rustic charm.
Brick walls, wooden tables, tall windows and cozy lighting give this place a warm and elegant atmosphere.
The smell of freshly baked pastries and garlic rings fills the air as you enjoy the various specialties of pizza, calzone, stromboli and other Italian delicacies.
Whether you're looking for a casual dinner spot or a place to share a slice and a story with friends, Ah' Pizz is the place to be.
what to order
Opt for their signature Ah' Pizz, topped with crushed tomato sauce, buffalo mozzarella and grape tomatoes.
It is so simple yet so divine.
2. Star Tavern
400 High Street
City of Orange, New Jersey 07050
(973) 675-3336
The Star Tavern is a family run bar and restaurant serving Italian specialties for over 65 years.
Why we recommend this pizzeria
No one makes the best pizza in and around Montclair quite like the family that has been perfecting it for generations.
At Star Tavern you can enjoy the cozy atmosphere of a classic neighborhood diner.
The nostalgic decor, retro disco lights, classic rock music and friendly staff create a welcoming and warm atmosphere.
Whether you're looking for a place to meet friends or just relax with a cold drink and a hot pizza, you'll find the perfect spot at Star Tavern.
what to order
We highly recommend going for their white spinach pizza.
This beautiful pastry is topped with ricotta, mozzarella cheese, roasted garlic and unique herbs.
It's earthy and strong, with some umami from the sauce.
Related: Must Eat Restaurants in Montclair
3. Pizzeria Trattoria Panzano
St. Walnut 71
Montclair, New Jersey 07042
(973) 744-4333
Panzano Pizzeria Trattoria is a local Italian pizzeria founded by the Latona brothers.
Why we recommend this pizzeria
If you're looking for Montclair's best pizza, you'll probably find it at the next place.
Panzano Pizzeria Trattoria offers a welcoming atmosphere that will transport you to the Italian countryside.
The rustic decor and cozy lighting create a welcoming and romantic atmosphere, making it the perfect place to enjoy a delicious meal with friends and family.
The food is deliciously homemade and Italian so every bite is a hit.
what to order
Their specialty is "Grandma's Pizza", a dish not to be missed.
Comes with cheese, basil, crushed tomato and top meat of your choice.
The combination of cheese and basil taste perfectly complements the spicy taste of the sauce.
4. Pan Dino's pizzeria and restaurant
Aleja Watchung 119
Montclair, New Jersey 07043
(973) 783-7110
Mr Dino's Pizzeria and Restaurant is a family owned business serving the Montclair community since 1981.
Why we recommend this pizzeria
When you hear someone say this place has the best pizza in your area, you better believe them.
You can enjoy the classic atmosphere of the old world Italian pizzeria with the addition of modern elegance.
It has a warm, welcoming interior with exposed brick walls, rustic wood accents and vintage Italian posters.
Enjoy delicious Italian cuisine in a relaxed, welcoming atmosphere, perfect for a night out with friends or family.
what to order
Their Four Seasons pizza is an explosion of flavors that make the perfect bite.
All served with a special tomato sauce, ham, olives, pepperoni and mushrooms.
The umami of the mushroom perfectly balances the spiciness of the pepperoni and the spicy olives bring it all together.
5. DaVinci brick oven pizza
223 Bellevue Ave
Montclair, New Jersey 07043
(973) 744-2300
DaVinci's Brick Oven Pizza has been a local staple for fresh, classic pizza for over 20 years.
Why we recommend this pizzeria
This next place makes the best pizza in downtown Montclair, and we're not exaggerating.
Walking into Da Vinci's is like walking into a restaurant in Italy.
Thanks to the classic Italian decor and warm atmosphere, it's impossible not to feel welcome.
Enjoy a handmade pizza cooked in a wood-fired oven or choose from a variety of other Italian dishes to suit your taste.
what to order
Choose a classic and order a Margherita pizza.
It's all topped with crushed, peeled imported Italian tomatoes, mozzarella, basil and pecorino romano cheese.
Everything on this pizza is imported from Italy, so you can bet it's the real deal.
6. Brick + Cake
St. Walnut 110
Montclair, New Jersey 07042
(973) 707-5153
Brick + Dough is a local pizzeria specializing in wood-fired pizza since 2019.
Why we recommend this pizzeria
As one of the best pizzerias in Montclair, Brick + Dough does a fantastic job of maintaining its reputation.
It offers a unique and warm dining experience that the locals can't get enough of.
The industrial-style decor creates a warm and welcoming atmosphere, with exposed brick walls, wooden tables and comfortable seating.
The restaurant also has an open kitchen where you can watch the food being prepared.
The whole thing is light and airy, so eating pizza here tastes like freedom.
If you don't think that makes sense, you'll see what we mean when you try it yourself.
what to order
Get the smoked mozzarella and bacon pizza.
The highlight of this pizza is the smoked mozzarella cheese and thick, crispy bacon.
The smoke of the mozzarella cheese creates a unique flavor that will enchant your taste buds.
The bacon adds a flavorful crunch to the pizza that provides a great textural contrast.
7. Willa Wiktoria pizzeria
St. Parkova 11
Montclair, New Jersey 07042
(973) 746-4426
Villa Victoria Pizzeria is a local Italian restaurant and pizzeria serving creative pizzas and traditional slices.
Why we recommend this pizzeria
In terms of both atmosphere and food, Villa Victoria is one of the best pizzerias in Montclair.
It's a bright and cheerful place where you'll feel like you're eating in a local restaurant on the streets of Rome.
The pizzas, pasta and other Italian delicacies are delicious and will impress the local Italians.
The whole place feels like a warm hug and is a great place to enjoy some simple, delicious Italian goodness.
what to order
The perfect custom-made cake is the classic Margherita pizza.
It has a light, airy crust, with spicy tomato, creamy mozzarella and fragrant basil.
Artfully crafted flavors come together to create a truly unforgettable pizza.
See also:
The best pizza in Jersey City
The best pizzerias in Bridgewater
Hamilton: Pizzeria
8. Enzo pizzeria and restaurant
150 Dolina Rd
Montclair, New Jersey 07042
(973) 509-0999
Enzo Pizzeria & Restaurant is a local, modern plate restaurant that has been serving classic pizza for over 30 years.
Why we recommend this pizzeria
This next part is the epitome of atmospheric, romantic and intimate.
The dark wood interior and dim lighting accenting the meal provide a quiet, elegant atmosphere.
It perfectly complements the menu consisting of delicious gourmet Italian dishes.
With outdoor seating and a cozy bar, you can spend an evening enjoying Italian cuisine, drinks and conversation in a relaxed and welcoming atmosphere.
what to order
Their signature pizza is topped with lots of freshly grated mozzarella cheese, juicy pepperoni slices and fragrant basil.
The pizza sauce is made daily on site, using only the freshest tomatoes, garlic and herbs.
9. Pizza Montclair w Belgiovine
712 Bloomfield Avenue
Montclair, New Jersey 07042
(973) 744-4402
Belgiovine's is a family pizzeria offering specialty and classic pizzas.
Why we recommend this pizzeria
Pizza Montclair in Belgiovine is the perfect place to enjoy a delicious slice of pizza in a cozy atmosphere.
Warm decoration and warm lighting create a comfortable and relaxing atmosphere.
It goes perfectly with gourmet cuisine inspired by Italian cuisine.
The pizzas are filled with fresh and delicious ingredients, prepared using traditional Italian techniques.
Overall, this is the perfect place for a fantastic slice of pizza.
what to order
Their signature dish, the Montclair Pizza, is an explosion of flavors and deliciousness.
It starts with a thin, crispy crust filled with cheese and topped with plenty of flavorful Italian sausage, sweet peppers and mushrooms.
The perfect combination of savory and sweet, the Montclair pizza is sure to satisfy your appetite.
10. Pizza i Grill Soho
540 Dolina Rd
Montclair, New Jersey 07043
(973) 744-8708
Soho Pizza and Grill is a family restaurant serving classic and specialty pizzas since 1999.
Why we recommend this pizzeria
Soho Pizza and Grill offers a relaxed and welcoming atmosphere, perfect for a casual lunch or dinner.
The restaurant is modern yet comfortable with light wood furniture, neutral and earthy tones and warm lighting that creates a relaxing atmosphere.
Enjoy delicious pizza, sandwiches and other Italian-American specialties in a fun and welcoming atmosphere.
what to order
Their specialty is the must-order Soho Supreme Pizza.
It is a delicious combination of fresh mozzarella, pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions, peppers and black olives.
The pizza is baked in a stone oven to give it the perfect texture and finished with a savory blend of herbs and spices.
See also:
The best pizzerias in Paramus
The best pizza in Parsippany
The best pizza in the Union
11. Wood-fired pizza and Italian restaurant Fiammella
558 Bloomfield Avenue
Montclair, New Jersey 07042
(862) 333-4135
Fiammella is a local BYOB Italian restaurant specializing in wood-fired pizza served in a rustic and welcoming setting.
Why we recommend this pizzeria
When it comes to atmosphere and the best pizza in Montclair, Fiamella has it all.
It is a warm, welcoming restaurant with a warm atmosphere and rustic Italian charm.
The pizza is baked in a traditional wood oven and the air is filled with the aroma of fresh tomatoes and herbs.
The items on the menu are prepared from the freshest ingredients and the dishes are always bursting with flavor and aroma.
The restaurant also has an intimate, family atmosphere, making it ideal for families.
what to order
Get the authentic wood-fired tomato pie and enjoy the perfect balance of flavors.
Sprinkle everything with fresh mozzarella, Parmigiano, basil, olive oil and crushed tomato.
Map of the best pizzerias in Montclair
Best Pizza in Montclair, New Jersey: Top 11 Pizza Places for 2023
- Ah, Pizza
- Star Tavern
- Pizzeria Trattoria Panzano
- Mr. Dino's pizzeria and restaurant
- DaVinci brick oven pizza
- Brick + Cake
- Willa Wiktoria pizzeria
- Enzo pizzeria and restaurant
- Montclair Pizza with Belgiovine
- Soho Pizza i Grill
- Wood-fired pizza and Italian restaurant Fiammella
